Concerns were mounting among football authorities and supporters in South Africa following the recent ruling by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS), which upheld FIFA’s decision to penalise Equatorial Guinea for fielding an ineligible player during the 2026 World Cup qualifiers.
The West African nation has been docked six points—three from each of their victories against Namibia and Liberia—after striker Emilio Nsue was found to be ineligible to represent the national team at the time of the matches. Nsue scored the winning goals in both fixtures, which ended in narrow 1-0 victories last November. However, FIFA later annulled those results, awarding 3-0 technical victories to Equatorial Guinea’s opponents in May.
The ruling arose from the finding that Nsue did not have the necessary clearance to switch his international allegiance from Spain, where he had participated at youth level. Despite having represented Equatorial Guinea for over a decade, FIFA declared his participation invalid, a decision that was upheld by CAS following an appeal lodged by the Equatorial Guinea Football Federation.
This ruling carries significant implications not only for Equatorial Guinea’s hopes of qualifying but also for South Africa, who may be facing a similar fate. The South African Football Association (SAFA) is currently subject to a FIFA investigation for fielding Teboho Mokoena in a Group C match against Lesotho in March. Mokoena had accrued two yellow cards in previous fixtures and should have been serving a suspension during that match. Should FIFA rule against South Africa, they risk losing the three points gained from the win over Lesotho.
Such a decision would dramatically alter the landscape of Group C. Currently sitting on 17 points, South Africa would drop to 14, putting them level with Benin. Nigeria, currently in third place with 11 points, could seize the opportunity to close the gap in the remaining rounds, particularly as they are set to face both Lesotho (away) and Benin (at home in Uyo).
For Namibia, the CAS ruling allows them to remain in second place in their group, thus preserving their pathway to the continental playoff round. Meanwhile, South Africa is left grappling with uncertainty as the situation unfolds.
